|
From:Simon Callow , Kate Winslet , Nicolas Cage , Jane Horrocks , Michael Gambon , CHRISTMAS CAROL - THE MOVIE (DVD MOVIE) , Jimmy T. Murakami , MGM (Video & DVD) ,
|
See Product Page
|
User Rating: Amazon Sales Rank:#15873 |
| | Page: << 1 2 >> |
 Brilliant despite dated animation, 2008-01-02
Being 22, I grew up knowing the story of the Christmas Carol in movies and theatrical shows. I tend to think that the one I saw most - the 1992 release - as being my favorite, but I happened upon this version during a cable TV special. I first thought, Oh geez another animated project...but I was surprised by the sheer depth, character and beautiful animation of this movie. The actors who voice the characters are brilliant (and Kate Winslet gives a stellar performance on the theme song, "What If") and the mice bring much needed fun to a rather serious kind of story; the animation is interesting (especially during the Ghost of Present scenes with the swirling colors and images intermixed with the gorgeous music), although a bit old in comparison to today's standards it is still a nice combination and very decent for the early 2000s. Overall, it's one of the best versions of the timeless story--a family favorite for sure!
One of the best, 2007-11-08
I have almost every version of a Christmas Carol there is, and this is one of my favorites. I can watch it over and over again. It does take some liberties with the story, but all in all, it is great! For all ages...
2 of 4 customers found the following review helpful:
 Bah Humbug!!, 2006-11-26
I received this dvd yesterday and have attempted to watch it 3 times and just cannot become interested in it. I have always been a huge Christmas cartoon fan and Christmas fan in general but this movie completely bores me and lacks the feeling of other versions that I have seen.
I gave it two stars for the theatrical beginning and ending being included in special features as I honestly enjoyed them, but the movie itself simply felt flat to me. To each his own though and if you decide to purchase this dvd I hope that you enjoy it. It just isn't one that I can recommend.
3 of 3 customers found the following review helpful:
 A Wonderful film, 2006-04-18
I just watched this version of the classic tale, and I am moved to tears. Forget what others here have said commenting on the animation, and pay attention to the story. The animation was superb with great use of shading and cg blends.
More importantly, this film has heart. It emotes. It conveys with power the ideals Dickens intended in his tale. Honor Christmas everyday. Keep its meaning and joy in your heart.
The only other animated film I have ever seen that comes close to this level of stroy telling and emotion is Grave of the Fireflies.
Buy this one. You will not be dissapointed. Share it with the family. Watch it on Christmas Eve. Watch it in July. Watch it whenever.
~William Nichols~
Best animation ever, 2005-01-25
Forget Shrek and The Polar Express. This little English film has the greatest animation ever. See for yourself!
|
| Page: << 1 2 >> |
|