|
From:Jane Green , Plume ,
|
See Product Page
|
User Rating: Amazon Sales Rank:#45418 |
| | Page: << 1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 21 >> |
 Never again., 2008-08-11
This book left a sour taste in my mouth. It's the first and only book I've read by Jane Green and I must admit, I'm not inclined to read the rest. The book moves much too quick for my liking and doesn't explain in enough detail anything. I would not recommend this book to anybody.
 Loved Mom, Hated Her, 2008-03-03
It's been a long time since I read a book in which I disliked the protagonist and liked the antagonist (Dan's mother Linda) so much. Ellie is in serious need of a psychiatrist, as her admittedly rocky childhood has left her with MAJOR issues. Linda, on the other hand, is a warm, loving, enthusiastic woman. Although she does tend to go overboard, I don't feel she's trying to run Dan & Ellie's lives. But everything she do angers Ellie to the point that she sometimes feels rage.
Admittedly I do understand why Ellie was dismayed when Linda bought all the baby things for her, even though I understand that it was the loving, generous gesture of a first time grandmother with much more disposable income than the parents have. She should have suggested a shopping trip for the two of them. I will grant that Linda doesn't think ahead often, but she does mean well.
As for the accident which ends up causing the breach between Ellie & Linda and eventually Dan & Linda's separation, I can understand Ellie's anger. Linda overstepped, but considering how little time she has been allowed with her grandchild, it is understandable. Ellie should have forgiven her.
I read this book shaking my head over Ellie's behavior & attitude. When someone suggested therapy, she said, "It's not my style." Perhaps not, but it was what she needed.
I imagine I will read more books by Jane Green; I hope I enjoy them more.
1 of 1 customers found the following review helpful:
 very witty, 2008-01-08
Jane green's writting style is simple and funny.
I have read a couple of her other books and this is my absolute favorite.
It is very witty. Ellie made me laugh and sometimes she would get on my nerves, but I recommend it. I loved the ending. Made me get emotional.
 Well-written, well-told story all women can relate to, 2007-12-02
Jane Green has the gift of gab - in written form! She tackled a topic all women can relate to - the overbearing, overly intrusive mother-in-law vs. you. Ellie, the main character, initially invites her prospective mother-in-law into her life because she was without a mother for most of hers. The invite turns imposing as she gets deeper into her marriage, making her husband the permanent referee. This book was so well done, I ordered 3 more Jane Green novels!!! Enjoy!
At last! A Jane Green book I liked!, 2007-11-16
I read both Bookends and To Have and to Hold and wasn't crazy about either of them. Those books were all plot with no character development. This book has at its center Ellie -- a 3 dimensional heroine with good qualities and bad. At times I ached for her, at other times I wanted to strangle her. I also really believed the way she changed as the book wore on.
|
| Page: << 1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 21 >> |
|